Catering Menu
How To Get A
Catering Order Estimate
Looking for a catering service with homestyle meals? You’ve come to the right place.
At Yoder’s Country Market, we offer catering for:
- Graduation Parties and Open Houses
- Birthday Parties and Family Reunions
- BBQs and Picnics
- Weddings, and More!
Our catering menu includes popular smoked and slow-cooked BBQ options we’re known for, plus sides like cheesy potatoes, green beans, salads, and more.
From fruit and veggie trays to full meals, talk to us about your custom catering order, and let us deliver a handmade meal for your special occasion.
We reserve the right to decline any catering order if not ordered far enough ahead of time (or if we have reached order capacity).
Entrées
An entrée is the most important part of any meal. We provide delicious BBQ meals, pastas, and comfort foods to impress your guests at every event.

Chicken
Chicken Halves
Cooked to perfection, our Chicken Halves are delicious on their own or paired with a salad, green beans, and a side of garlic mashed potatoes.
$ 5.49/each (minimum of 20 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersBoneless Chicken Breast
Made with or without barbecue sauce, our succulent Boneless Chicken Breast goes well with any side dish.
$ 4.50/each (minimum of 20 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersChicken Leg Quarters
A savory delight for all barbecue lovers, these leg quarters are slow-cooked to achieve an enticing smoky flavor. Enjoy with or without our house BBQ sauce.
$ 1.99/each (minimum of 30 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersBoneless Chicken Thighs
Tender, juicy, and cooked to perfection, Boneless Chicken Thighs are an ideal meal for any occasion.
$ 2.99/each (minimum of 30 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersWings
Infused with smoky barbecue flavor, our wings are sure to impress you and your guests. Opt for sauce for an extra flavor kick, or enjoy them delightfully seasoned.
$ .99/each (minimum of 100 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersTaco Chicken
Our Taco Chicken meat makes light work of making tacos. Simplify parties and get-togethers with the main course already seasoned and cooked to perfection for you.
$ 8.49/per lb (minimum of 5 lb per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all orders

Beef
Beef Brisket
Treat yourself to our BBQ-style Brisket—every meat lover's dream. Our brisket is slow-cooked to perfect tenderness, with the rich marbling slowly melting to infuse the meat with juicy flavor.
Market Price (minimum of 5 lb per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersPot Roast
A nostalgic and comforting dish, our roast includes deep, rich flavors and is melt-in-your-mouth tender. Try this perfect dish for Sunday meals or any day of the week.
Market Price (minimum of 5 lb per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersMeatballs (1oz)
We create our meatballs with only the finest grade of ground beef and spices. Top with our house BBQ sauce or enjoy this dish plain. Either way, this entrée makes for an unforgettable main course.
$ 1.00/each
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersTaco Beef
Generously seasoned for tacos, nachos, quesadillas, and more, our Taco Beef is an tasty option for your next party. Mix it up by making taco bowls or taco salads for a healthier alternative.
$ 8.49/per lb (minimum of 5 lb per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all orders

Pork
Baby Back Ribs
Our Baby Back Ribs fall off the bone and are packed full of flavor. Try pairing this entrée with corn or green beans and a side salad.
$ 19.00/per rack (minimum of 10 per order)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersDinner Slice of Ham
Take the work out of carving your own ham and place an order for our savory, smoky ham slices that promise satisfaction. Add a side of mashed potatoes and green beans for a full meal.
$ 2.50/each
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all ordersPulled Pork
Choose between sauced or sauceless Pulled Pork for melt-in-your-mouth pulled pork sandwiches, tacos, nachos, and more.
$ 9.49 (unsauced, per lb)
$ 8.99 (unsauced, over 10 lb)
$ 7.99 (sauced, per lb)
$ 7.49 (sauced, over 10 lb)
5-7 days’ notice is needed on all orders

Pasta
Lasagna
Cheesy layers, flavor-packed pasta sauce, and Italian herbs stand out with our Lasagna recipe. Good enough to eat on its own (or with a side salad), add this tasty dish to your meal prep list.
$ 33.99 (9-12 servings)
$ 67.98 (18-21 servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all ordersChicken Alfredo
Rich, parmesan flavor comes through in every bite of our creamy Chicken Alfredo. Made for special occasions of all kinds, serve this dish solo or with a side salad.
$ 33.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 67.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all ordersMac & Cheese
Mac and Cheese is a timeless combination. Whether you enjoy this as a side or topped with pulled pork or brisket, this cheesy pasta is sure to fill you up.
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all ordersBeef/Chicken & Noodles
Beef or chicken paired with egg noodles adds warmth to any meal. Savor the flavor and seasonings of homestyle cooking in every bite of this classic dish.
$ 27.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 55.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all ordersSpaghetti
Spaghetti is the perfect complement to our handmade meatballs. Create a full meal with spaghetti and meatballs already prepped and ready to serve!
$ 27.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 55.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Comfort Foods
Mashed Potatoes
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Cheesy Potatoes
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Loaded Red Skin Potatoes
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Chicken Enchiladas
$ 32.99 (9-12 servings)
$ 65.98 (18-21 servings)Egg Casserole
A traditional Amish breakfast food
$ 29.99 (9-12 servings)
$ 59.98 (18-21 servings)Beef Gravy
$ 15.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 31.98 (30 half-cup servings)Chicken Gravy
$ 15.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 31.98 (30 half-cup servings)Sausage Gravy
$ 27.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 55.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
Soups
There’s nothing quite like the comfort of homemade soup. Try our heart-warming options for your next get together with family and friends.

Homemade Soups
Chicken Noodle
Chicken Corn Chowder
Cheeseburger
Cheesy Broccoli
Chili
Spicy Veggie
Stuffed Green Pepper
White Chicken Chili
$ 24.99 (1/2 gallon)
$ 49.99 (1 gallon)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
Sides
From leafy greens to baked beans, our side dishes simplify planning for your next event. Choose one or more sides to create the perfect combo.

Vegetables
Green Beans
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Corn
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Baked Beans
$ 24.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 49.98 (30 half-cup servings)Cowboy Beans
$ 27.99 (15 half-cup servings)
$ 55.98 (30 half-cup servings)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Salads
Potato Salad
Red-Skin Potato Salad
Broccoli Salad
Grape Salad
Chicken Salad
Crab Salad
Three Bean Salad
Pickle Salad
Creamy Coleslaw
Pasta Salad
Macaroni Salad
Mixed Fruit Salad
Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad
Ham Salad
Southwest Black Bean
Keto Cauliflower
All salads are sold by the pound. Quantity discounts available.
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
*Other salad types are available for purchase. Please contact us for more options.
Trays
Simplify special occasions with veggie, fruit, or meat and cheese—specially customized for your get-togethers.

Meat & Cheese
Our Meat and Cheese trays can be customized to your liking and accommodate small or large gatherings. Meats and cheeses can be sandwich sliced or cubed.
$ 38.99 (10-15 people)
$ 54.99 (15-20 people)
$ 76.99 (25-35 people)
$ 109.99 (50-70 people)
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Veggie Tray
Savory, crunchy, and satisfying, our Veggie Trays only include your favorite options (per your request). Plus, each tray comes with premade vegetable dip, so you don’t have to stress about making your own.
$ 31.99 (10-15 people)
$ 43.99 (15-20 people)
$ 67.99 (25-35 people)
$ 95.99 (50-70 people)
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Fruit Tray
Choose from fresh strawberries, blueberries, mangoes, and and other seasonal fruits for your next event.
$ 31.99 (10-15 people)
$ 43.99 (15-20 people)
$ 67.99 (25-35 people)
$ 95.99 (50-70 people)
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Mini Croissant Tray
Take your event to the next level by providing your favorite light (and savory) meal.
Filled with chicken salad or a savory salad of your choice, our mini Croissant Tray brings texture and flavor to any gathering. Enjoy these sandwiches on their own, or pair with a BBQ entree for added protein.
Available in: Ham Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad, and
Turkey or Ham, Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad, and Jon’s Favorite (3 Meat)
$ 3.00 (each)
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Sub Sandwiches
Sold by the footlong, our sub trays offer the same customization as our in-store subs, but are made to satisfy the entire crowd.
$ 11.99 (each, sold by the footlong)
24 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
All sub trays come with a tray of condiments.
Desserts
Making dessert for a crowd doesn’t have to take up all your time. Choose from cookies, pies, and bars to bring something sweet to the table.

Rolls & Bars
Pumpkin Bars
Blueberry Kuffin
$ 6.79 (8” x 8” pan, serves 6-8 people)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Cake
Banana Cake
$ 6.79 (8” x 8” pan, serves 6-8 people)
Chocolate Sheet Cake
$ 6.79 (8” x 8” pan, serves 6-8 people)
Carrot Cake
$ 6.79 (8” x 8” pan, serves 6-8 people)
Cheesecake Delights
$ 14.99 (8” x 8” pan, serves 6-8 people)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Cookies
Classic Cookies
Enjoy a dozen of our classic cookies available in: Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Crinkle, Ma’s Sugar Cookies, Molasses, Monster, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, and Snickerdoodle
$ 6.99 (1 dozen)
Deluxe Cookies
Prep for a special event with deluxe cookies available in: Sour Cream Cutouts, Buttermilk, and No Bake Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies
Sour Cream Cutouts: $ 7.49 (8 count)
Buttermilk: $ 9.69 (8 count)
No Bake Peanut Butter Chocolate Cookies: $ 6.99 (1 dozen)Assorted Cookie Tray
$ 8.30 (1 dozen)
$ 18.29 (2 dozen)
$ 26.90 (3 dozen)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Fruit Pies
Apple
Dutch Apple
Black Raspberry
Red Raspberry
Blueberry
Cherry
Peach
Strawberry Rhubarb
Rhubarb
$ 6.29 (6” pie)
$ 13.99 (9” pie)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders

Cream Pies
Custard
Banana Cream
Peanut Butter
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate Pudding
Lemon Cream
Coconut Cream
Raspberry Cream
Strawberry Cream
Lemon Meringue
Pumpkin
Pecan
$ 6.99 (6” pie)
$ 14.99 (9” pie)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
Ask about our seasonal pies for more flavor options.

Reduced-Sugar Pies
Apple
Cherry
Blueberry
$ 6.99 (6” pie)
$ 14.99 (9” pie)
48 hours’ notice is needed on all orders
Estimate
Receive A Catering Order
Need an estimate for what it will cost to cater your event? Fill out the form below, and we’ll contact you with a price and our availability!
